Quackery Exposed: Fecal Microbiota Transplant


Fecal transplant is another treatment said to cure autism. Recently in the news, Melissa Eaton exposed them. What is Fecal Microbiota Transplant (FMT)?

FMT is a procedure that delivers healthy human donor stool to a patient via colonoscopy, enema, nasogastric tube, or in capsules (known as poop pills). It is only prescribed for serious C. Diff infections. 

  • C. diff is a serious infection — one that causes debilitating diarrhea and in the U.S., in 2011 alone, C. diff was responsible for 29,000 deaths in adults. Treating C. diff begins with administering antibiotics; however, recurrence is common. By the third episode of severe C. diff, it is unlikely antibiotics will cure the infection; so, your child’s doctor may consider FMT as an option. It is still an experimental procedure and should only be done under medical intervention. 

How does FMT work?

The GI tract has an “ecosystem” of thousands of bacteria and other organisms that help keep the body healthy. When your child is given an antibiotic, this ecosystem is disrupted, allowing the growth of disease-causing bacteria, such as C. diff.
With a fecal transplant, “good” microorganisms from the donor stool are infused into the patient. Healthy bacteria begin to grow and prevent C. diff from recurring.
Stool donors are rigorously screened and stool samples are extensively tested before being used for FMT
About the FMT procedure
  • Colonoscopy: A thin hollow tube with an attached camera is placed up the colon and a catheter-tipped syringe is used to inject donor stool through the channel.
  • Enema: Although, less invasive than a colonoscopy, a fecal enema often needs to be performed more than once, because the donor stool doesn’t reach the colon.
  • Nasogastric (NG) tube: Using a thin, flexible feeding tube, doctors insert donor stool through a patient’s nostril, down the throat and into the stomach.
  • Oral capsules, known as “poop pills.”
The long-term results of FMT are unknown, so you’ll need to sign an informed-consent form on behalf of your child.
To prepare for the transplant, your child should have an empty GI tract. This often means drinking only clear fluids and abstaining from eating for 24 hours before the procedure.
If your child has mild or moderate C. diff, they may also be asked to drink a liquid to encourage a bowel movement; however, children with more severe infections will not follow this same protocol.


Risks of FMT

When the procedure is used for its intended purpose, there is a risk of infection transmission. There are the HIV, hepatitis and retrovirus. In the proper setting, all donor stool is tested thoroughly to minimize this. 

It is an experimental procedure. There are many risks that are unknown. To undergo this is very risky. 

Study Disproves this Quack Theory

There has been much talk about the role of gut biome in autism.They believes that there is a role in gut biome causing autism.  The autistic community had said it was bunk for a long time but science finally proves it’s bogus. It has been proven that gut biome in autistic people are different than non autistic people. There is a very good reason for this.
The different gut biome is due to autistic people being picky eaters.
A study that was published in the scientific journal Cell disproves this theory and the autistic community is rejoicing. The study worked with the Australian Autism Biobank. This includes extensive clinical and biological data from autistic children and their families. It also included the Queensland Twin Adolescent Brain Project.
They compared microbial DNA from stool samples of 99 autistic children to 2 groups of non autistic children. 51 of their siblings and 97 unrelated children. They also looked at clinical, family and lifestyle information. This includes the diet as well.
They found no evidence for a relationship between autism and measures of the microbiome as a whole, or with microbiome diversity.
Only one bacterial species out of more than 600 showed an association with autism. They found no evidence for other bacterial groups that have been previously reported in autism.
Instead, they found autistic children were more likely to be picky eaters, which is consistent with earlier studies and this was related to autistic traits such as sensory sensitivity and special interests.
They also found that pickier eaters tended to have a less diverse microbiome and runnier stool. This can cause some autistic children to have gastrointestinal issues.

FMT Doctor Under Investigation in Canada

Dr Jason Klop has been under investigation since 2019 for the use of FMT on autistic children. He took these children on “retreats” to Mexico and the practice is illegal in the United States and Canada.

2 thoughts on “Quackery Exposed: Fecal Microbiota Transplant

  1. Pingback: Bogus Study: Cutting Edge: Critical Roles For Microbiota-Mediated Regulation of the Immune System in Prenatal Immune Activation Model of Autism – Fierce Autie

  2. Pingback: Quack Exposed: Jason Klop – Fierce Autie

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s